Uncharitable politics
As a lot of you know, I support a lot of NGOs. A lot of those NGOs do work in respect of the environment, animal welfare, and so on.
In recent months, I have been hearing from worried NGOs – over and over – that they have been targeted by federal Conservatives over their charitable status. If they lose that status, they lose the ability to operate.
The Cons – federally and provincially – have been targeting organizations who take public positions they disapprove of (you know, the environment is good, animal abuse is bad, etc.). They have been sending around bureaucrats to tell NGOs that they are “under review.” The message has been clear: if you continue to advocate in a way we don’t like, you will lose your charitable status. Federally, Conservatives have gone after a very well-known environmentalist, because they don’t like the things he says. They want to put him out of business.
Here’s where you come in.
I’m collecting information about this McCarthyite practice for a possible column, and (for certain) my next book. If you have any information about that, I’d love to hear from you, at wkinsella@hotmail.com. Confidentiality guaranteed.
This is the worst kind of politics – and it has to stop. Disagreeing with NGOs is fine. But using the power of government to bankrupt NGOs you disagree with? That isn’t fine.
Andrea Horwath thinks this is a defence of Anthony Marco (updated)
At the International Ploughing Match, the media asked the Ontario NDP leader about Marco’s comments – that National Socialism is a religion, and that those who object to Naziism and its variants are “pretty messed up.”
She angrily denounced those who were critical of Marco, and she refused to discipline him. She also suggested his full remarks, in context, somehow validate Marco’s position. Here are his full remarks:
“Don’t tell me that there’s a separation of church and state right now, because when people talk about the religious right, there’s two words that just married church and state pretty f***in’ quick didn’t they? And if you’re going to talk about a book burning, may I suggest that over the next little while, if you’re going to burn books, and for the most part I would never advocate burning books, because you know books are, when I read a book, even as bad as the book is, I’m that type of person that doesn’t throw books away, I’ve got books all over the place. Maybe someday I should throw books away, but I don’t throw them away. But there are a couple of ones that I would suggest burning. And you know what, it’s not even from an ideological perspective, like ‘oh well, burn stuff by Adolf Hitler,” no. Whatever. If you want to read that stuff, read that stuff. For some people the old politics of Nazi Germany might be their religion. And just as I can’t condemn other people’s religion, I can’t, I don’t agree with them, but you can’t stop somebody from believing in something. And to bash your head against the wall trying, it’s not their fault, it’s your fault. You’re the one who is pretty messed up if you’re going to devote your entire life to trying to convince somebody not to believe what they believe. So if you’re going to be burning books over the next little while, I suggest not burning books for a while…”
That sound like an effective defence to you? Me neither. It still sounds like a bloody fool who is wholly indifferent to Naziism, and who also thinks Mein Kampf is worth checking out.
Anyway. The issue now is Andrea Horwath. Why would she not condemn her candidate’s remarks? Why would she not discipline him?
Is it because she agrees with him?
The NDP won’t fire the candidate who made the comment about Nazis
Harper-Hudak “hat trick” video: it’s still being taken down on YouTube
….but you can get it here!
August 2, 2011: Stephen Harper calls for a “hat trick” – for Conservatives to run the country, the GTA and Ontario. Almost every day since: Conservative operatives scramble to suppress any record of Harper’s statement.
Download this video, and share it with others before voting day on October 6! You can download the file here.
Download also found here.
NDP candidate: those who fight Nazis are “pretty messed up”
Liberals Call on NDP to Dump Candidate
NDP Candidate says he can’t condemn Nazi politics because it’s just “other people’s religion”
Toronto – – The NDP should dump candidate Anthony Marco (Niagara West-Glanbrook) over comments posted to his website saying he can’t condemn Nazi politics because it’s just other people’s religion.
In a podcast on his website, lovehatethings.com, Marco goes on to say those who devote themselves to fighting Nazis are “pretty messed up.”
“For some people the old politics of Nazi Germany might be their religion. And just as I can’t condemn other people’s religion, I can’t, I don’t agree with them, but you can’t stop somebody from believing in something… You’re the one who is pretty messed up if you’re going to devote your entire life to trying to convince somebody not to believe what they believe.”
Liberal candidate Bernie Farber (Thornhill), former CEO of the Canadian Jewish Congress, says NDP Leader Andrea Horwath has no choice but to dump her candidate.
“I’ve devoted my life to this cause, and there is no place in Ontario politics for someone who doesn’t understand that Nazis and everything they stood for deserves condemnation,” said Liberal candidate Bernie Farber. “He needs to go.”
Radwanski in today’s Globe
Worth a read. Quote:
In today’s Sun: why Topps is at the top
Interesting column in Ottawa Citizen
…about which there will be no comment!
Report: The video Harper and Hudak wanted to kill
In the video, Harper calls for a Conservative hat-trick in Ontario saying, “We’ve cleaned up the left-wing mess federally in this area, Rob’s doing it municipally, and now we’ve got to complete the hat-trick and do it provincially as well.”
Apparently, Conservatives don’t want Canadians to see the video:
Every time the video has appeared on YouTube, it’s been taken down – at the request of the federal Conservatives.
The Toronto Star reported the Prime Minister’s Office placed calls to organizers as soon as the video went up in early August. Guest lists were sought in a bid to find who had posted it to YouTube and by the next morning, it was down.
A spokesperson for Harper would only say the video had been removed by the person who posted it.
The new version of the video, posted on Liberal insider Warren Kinsella’s blog, claims “the Prime Minister’s Office and Conservative party operatives hired lawyers to suppress the hat-trick video.
“Every time it shows up, the Conservatives sue and it gets taken down again,” notes text in the video.
In a column in the Hill-Times, Kinsella says Harper’s office doesn’t want Canadians to view the video because it could hurt the Ontario PCs’ chances in the upcoming provincial election.
“Harper’s remarks were a disaster,” he wrote
“The PMO scrambled, comically, to scrub the evidence from the Internet but it was too late. Ontario voters — female voters in particular — saw what he said, and they didn’t like it . . . Ontarions do not want the same wrecking crew running everything.”