Categories for Musings

CBC, Israel, Jews and the truth

Media truth.

For many, those words are an oxymoron – you know, two words that have the opposite meaning of the other. For many supporters of Israel and Western democracy, these days, “media truth” is just that. An oxymoron.

So: the New York Times, the ostensible newspaper of record, placing a photo of a child on its front page, and then falsely suggesting it was dying as a result of an Israeli campaign of starvation against Palestinians. Or most other media simply ignoring authentic footage of a skeletal Israeli man being forced by Hamas to dig his own grave – whose “state,” by the by, Canada just announced it would formally recognize.

The media has lost tremendous credibility over cases like these. Media have also lost a lot of legitimacy for playing fast and loose with the truth in the Israel-Hamas war.

The CBC, which all Canadian pay for with their taxes, has been among the notable offenders. Instead of presenting verifiable facts in a fair and balanced way, it has seemingly chosen sides, and presented a wildly-distorted view of the Hamas-Israel conflict.

This reporter has documented multiple examples of that at CBC. Many relate to Mohamed El Saife. 

El Saife is paid by CBC to work as a “videographer.” A fawning essay about him was posted on the main CBC website at the anniversary of the slaughter of hundreds of Jews by Hamas, October 7. A similarly-sycophantic profile of him was broadcast on CBC’s main news programs, on both CBC News Network and on its main network. There, he was described as CBC’s “eyes and ears” in Gaza.

His “eyes and ears” apparently see and hear things differently than many of us. El Saife says “Israel” — he puts the Jewish state’s name in quotation marks, to suggest that it is a fiction — is an “occupation army that violates the dignity of of the bodies of martyrs.” He has accused Israel of “massacring” citizens in the Gazan city of Khan Yunis, without any proof.

He has published an A.I.-generated image of a Palestinian child wearing wings, and chased by demonic-looking weapons-toting IDF troops.

And, now, we learn about a new example of CBC’s “eyes and ears in Gaza” conducting himself in manner that many journalists never would: the raw footage he sends that is ultimately seen by hundreds of the network’s journalists. These are actual quotes from the footage – the “shot lists” – he sells to CBC:

[To read more, subscribe here]


This is what Canada recognized

A Thai man is lying on the ground. He seems to be bleeding from a gunshot wound to his chest. The man moves his arms, a bit.

A Gazan man, one not in a Hamas uniform, takes a hoe, and starts hacking at the man’s neck, over and over. It makes a thick, crunching sound every time it lands.

It is apparent the Gazan is trying to behead the Thai man, who came to Israel to work on a farm. “God is great!” he shrieks, over and over, as he brings down the blade on the man’s neck.

Not far away, at yellow metal gate leading to the Be’eri kibbutz – which is just up the road from the site of the Nova Music Festival – a man drives up in his car, waiting for the gate to slide open. Uniformed Hamas terrorists step out from some bushes and shoot the man. He’s dead. His car slowly slides forward, and comes to rest against the gate.

The terrorists fire off a few more rounds into the man’s body, and then walk into the kibbutz. They creep past rows of single-story white homes, mostly silent. On the GoPro footage they are collecting, they can be heard whispering to each other: “Where did they go?” They are looking for Jews to kill.

[To read more, subscribe here]


Israel needs to change the channel – and change its leader

Someone really needs to reacquaint Benjamin Netanyahu with the 1988 Hamas Charter. Quickly. 

In particular, they need to show the Israeli Prime Minister articles 10 and 30. In those, in their governing document, Hamas says that it will use “word and deed” to wage Jihad – which has come to mean holy war. 

Article 30 is pretty specific: “Jihad is not confined to the carrying of arms and the confrontation of the enemy. The effective word, the good article, the useful book, support and solidarity – all these are elements of the Jihad for Allah’s sake.”

In other words, propaganda. What the terror organization is telling everyone, here, is that they wage war with words and images just as much as bombs and bullets. Implicitly, Hamas has always acknowledged that their desired genocide of Jews and infidels is a daunting military challenge. Propaganda, however, is Hamas’ real forte. At that, they excel.

So, in the information war, Hamas – and its axis, with Hezbollah and Iran and Qatar and Russia and China – is winning. You only need to cast your eye over the offerings of most news or social media – or look at what is happening in the streets – to see that is true. Israel is losing the propaganda war. It is getting its ass kicked.

Netanyahu is a big part of the reason. Israel’s leader is propped up by a coalition of far right religious extremists, and adamantly refuses to let anyone else speak for Israel in the West. He has been in power too long, and the majority – inside and outside of Israel – are weary of him.

But Benjamin Netanyahu alone cannot be fairly blamed for all of the grave harm that has been done to Israel’s reputation. Hamas is the main author of that.

Since the beginnings of the war in late October 2023, Hamas’ propagandists have completely dominated the news and information agenda. When an IDF tank moves through Gaza streets, for example, Hamas typically sends out four men: two to attach explosives to the side of the tank, one to guard the getaway – and one to shoot broadcast quality propaganda footage.

Even with its leadership and its ranks decimated, Hamas and its axis never give up on propagandizing. Look at the evidence.

[To read more, subscribe here]


Canada, tweeting from the sidelines

When a country doesn’t matter militarily or diplomatically, when no one is sharing intelligence with it anymore, all that it has left are…empty words, basically. Piety and preaching. That’s it.

So, now, when it comes to world affairs, Canada is a season’s ticket holder in the nosebleed seats. Holding up homemade signs, hollering, hoping to get on TV, while the real action is playing out elsewhere, far, far away.

Ever since 2004, when Paul Martin and his brain trust thought it would be a good idea to meet the homicidal Libyan dictator Muammar Qaddafi in a tent in the desert, Canada has mattered less and less internationally. It all happened gradually. We became a bit of an afterthought, and then a punchline. Donald Trump, in particular, knows this. He’s noticed that the rest of the world hasn’t rallied to our side, as he’s openly coveted us as his 51st state.

It was not always thus. At one time – say, when Mike Pearson won a Nobel Peace Prize in 1964 for resolving the Suez Crisis, or when Brian Mulroney fought to end apartheid in the Eighties, or when Jean Chretien refused to participate in George W. Bush’s war against Saddam Hussein in 2003 – Canada truly mattered on the international stage. Not so much anymore.

In recent years, we’ve been reduced to thumbing out sanctimonious tweets from the sidelines, far removed from the action. In both official languages, bien sur.

So, Prime Minister Mark Carney issued a tweet on Thursday. Here’s part of what it said:

“Canada condemns the Israeli government’s failure to prevent the rapidly deteriorating humanitarian disaster in Gaza. Israel’s control of aid distribution must be replaced by comprehensive provision of humanitarian assistance led by international organizations. Many of these are holding significant Canadian-funded aid which has been blocked from delivery to starving civilians. This denial of humanitarian aid is a violation of international law.”

[To read more, subscribe here]


Lorna Emma Bridget Cleary Kinsella

Use your thumb for the clouds, my Mom said.

It was the pandemic. My life had blown up, I was living with two labs in an old farmhouse on an island, and nobody was allowed to go near anyone else.

Creatively, I didn’t have another book in me. My band couldn’t get together to play. I had given up writing for newspapers. So, I decided to paint again.

My ex hadn’t let me put my art up on the walls, you see, so I had just stopped. I went along with what she wanted. I did that.

So I dug out some paint and brushes and sat down at the long table in the dining room. The first one was a scene from around here, from a photo I took while riding my bike way out along a trail. A field of canola and a line of trees.  And a sky.

It looked okay; it was okay. But the clouds, which reached across the sky like a god’s fingers? I couldn’t get them right. I called my Mom.

She was an artist. Her paintings hung in galleries and homes across Canada. She was alone, too, because of the pandemic, but we talked on the phone every single day, twice a day. Morning and night.

“Use your thumb,” she said to me. “Not your brush. Use your thumb.”

So I did. And it worked. It was right. I was proud of it, so I put a photo of it up on the Internet. Right away, an old friend in Ottawa said she wanted to buy it. When I was sure she wasn’t joking, I sent it to my friend. And my Mom was happy.

“See?” she said. “You’re an artist. You’ll be better than me in no time.”

I wasn’t, of course. I’m not. I’ll never be as good as she was, in every conceivable way. But painting made me feel something I hadn’t felt in ten years – joy – and so I kept going.  There’s been dozens of paintings since then, and even an art show. She coached me and advised me through all of it.

My Mom, Lorna Emma Bridget Cleary Kinsella, coached me and my brothers through all of our lives, too, until we grew up and moved away. Despite the distance, she remained the bond that kept us all together – my Dad, my three brothers.  She was the centre.

She was raised by a single mother, the original feminist, Irene Cleary.  There were seven of them in their smallish apartment in Montreal, two sons and five daughters.  My Mom was the oldest girl.

Sons often think of their mothers as beautiful, but ours truly was. She was this radiant, dark-haired beauty from Montreal’s North End.  She looked like Elizabeth Taylor, people would often say, and she did.  She was beautiful in her heart, too.

She met my father, an aspiring doctor and future military officer, at a dance when she was 17.  She told us she knew he was the one.  She waited for him, declining (many) other suitors. They married in 1955 at the chapel at Loyola, where he had gone to high school and college.

My Dad was a doctor, but he was not a wealthy man.  He believed that health care was a right of citizenship, and that no one should ever profit from illness.  My mother believed that, too. So, while we were not poor, we were not ever rich.  We didn’t eat out much, we didn’t have fancy vacations.  My Mom cooked everything, and made her own clothes, and rehabilitated abandoned furniture.  And she painted.

She loved Canadian scenes, but she loved painting children and old people, too.  Many times – and still, now – people say to me she had a Group of Seven style, one that revealed her deep love of this country. Her works were always sought after, but she was modest.  We’d tell her she didn’t sell them for enough.

She taught art.  She studied art.  Growing up, there was always the smell of oil paints and linseed oil in our family homes in Montreal, Dallas, Kingston and Calgary.  Her art – and the art of others – filled our walls, and was often stacked up when there was no more room.

She always insisted we call, no matter how late, to say where we were and how we were getting home. She laughed (and defended me) when teachers told her I was a radical and a trouble-maker. She tolerated the punk rock racket coming up the back stairs, because she said she liked knowing where we all were.  My best friends, in their biker jackets and skinny jeans and homemade Clash T-shirts, would always gather at my house – to see my Mom and Dad, I suspected, and not so much me.  My friends still call them “our other parents.”

Our home always radiated warmth and love, and my Mom was at the centre of it. When our Dad died in Kingston in 2004, all of us expected she wouldn’t stay there – that she would move to Toronto, where we were.  But she didn’t.  She remained in Kingston for ten more years with her little dog Maggie, and kept painting, and she kept declining expressions of interest from men. “They’re not your father,” she’d say.  “There will never be a man as beautiful as he was, for me.”

She came to Toronto, eventually, but never got the hang of the place. (Few do.) When the pandemic arrived, she and I would meet at the fence on her main-floor balcony in the Beach, and I would give her canvases and brushes and paint. Titanium white was hard to find during Covid, but I got some for her. For the clouds, maybe.

She painted. She made it through, never getting sick.  And, when it was finally over, that all changed. She was 90 years old, and she fought it.  But cancer finally claimed her on this day one year ago, just as it had taken my Dad, 19 years and one month before.

I have one painting of hers, now, raised up higher at my house than all the others, so that I can always see it.  It is of a river, moving past some trees, a reddish sky is seen through their branches.  On the left, there is a white patch of canvas, with no paint on it.  It is where she stopped, perhaps because the end was near. Would it have been a bit of cloud? Would she have used her thumb?

Now, I look at her art on my walls and marvel at her talent, and marvel at the boundless beauty of her.  And I marvel, too, at how blessed I was to be the son of Lorna Emma Bridget Cleary Kinsella, who was an artist and my mother, and who I love and miss with all my heart.